David R. MacIver's Blog
Training in moral realism
Disclaimer: I am not a philosopher, actual philosophers are probably frustrated by how I do philosophy.
The question of moral realism, simplified probably to the point of parody, is “Do moral claims have objective truth, or are they just something humans make up?”.
You can imagine a spectrum ranging from something like… there exists a purely universal objective theory of morality that precisely quantifies the goodness or badness of each action, and there is always deterministically the best choice to make, and a complete characterisation of the what the best sort of person you can be is on one hand, and on the other hand you have something like pure emotivism, where a moral judgement just means that I disapprove (or approve).
This spectrum doesn’t really exhaust the possibilities, in the sense that you can imagine a wide variety of moral theories and frameworks at any given point on it, some of them more reasonable than others, but it’s a not unreasonable starting point.
A position I’ve taken for a while, which sits somewhere on the middle of the spectrum, is that morality is like running. It is a practice, directed towards some end, that is to a large degree contingent on specifics of the human condition, but contains many objective and some subjective considerations that affect it. You aren’t free to take an anything goes position in morality any more than you are in running - some ways of running really are objectively worse than others. If you run backwards with your hands on your head, you will be worse at running than if you run normally. On the other hand, the optimal way of running for a sprint is different than the optimal way of running for a marathon, the optimal way of running for you may be different than it is for me, etc. There are also aesthetic considerations of style and form - there have been a number of cases where the world record is broken by someone and everyone looks at what they did and thinks it looks really weird and awkward. Sometimes that gets adopted and we make progress in the technology of running, sometimes it just gets disregarded because it looks “obviously wrong”.
I could go on about this analogy further, but I won’t. I’m just trying to explain my basic position, because the actual thing I wanted to note is that I ran into what is, to me, an interesting example of an objective moral truth recently: Let people off the train before boarding.
As I complained about recently, I’m commuting most days of the week now, and as a result I am quite aware of the various ways people behave badly on public transport. Of these, one of the ones that annoy me the most is violations of what I genuinely regard as this objectively correct moral principle. People stand in front of the train doors and try to get on board when there are clearly people still trying to get off.
Part of why this is objectively wrong is that when you do this there is absolutely no advantage to you. It is a strictly worse experience than just waiting - you are shoving your way through people rather than waiting for a clear space. You are delaying the train. It cannot and will not leave until they are off and you are on, a process that you are delaying to your minor inconvenience and their major inconvenience. Due to a lack of basic thought and consideration, you are making the world worse for everyone around you, to literally no advantage to yourself. There is no world in which this is a reasonable thing to do, therefore the only reason to do it is a lack of basic thought and care for the system in which you participate.
This is, I admit, how I feel about a lot of things, and I acknowledge that I probably have an overly developed sense of duty about how people occupy shared spaces. For example, a recurring thought of mine is “Hey asshole, you know why it’s called a chokepoint? It’s because I want to choke you when you stand there. Stop blocking the flow of people!” when people stand somewhere that clearly everyone needs to get through (for example, most tube stations have a very narrow area right at the bottom of the stairs down where you need to go either left or right at the bottom to get to the right platform. If you loiter there, now everyone trying to get to the trains is blocked behind you).
Most of these, I don’t consider to be objectively morally wrong in the same way as the boarding example is, even if they are sometimes in some sense more harmful (or at least ruder/more inconsiderate, depending on where you set the threshold for “harm”). They are selfish, but I consider there to be some legitimate room for disagreement on how much selfishness is appropriate. You are not required to be maximally convenient to those around you. It is a key part of the boarding example that it is self defeating. An optimally selfish individual would also not do it, because it gives them no advantage. This behaviour is, to me, still clearly immoral and I will express that partly by refusing to engage in it and partly by communicating where possible that it is out of line.
Another example a bit like boarding is anyone who stops at the top of an escalator. This is not, technically speaking, self-defeating in quite the same way I suppose. It is actively very dangerous, but it doesn’t get in the way of your own objectives in the same way. It is however effectively self-defeating, because I will fucking bodycheck you if you do this, and you presumably don’t want that to be happen. Other people might be less aggressive about this than me, but this is to some degree a forced outcome because there’s a long line of people behind you who are being mechanically shoved into you.
As you are probably noticing, I have a large number of public transportation related moral opinions. Some of this is just because I have a large number of moral opinions, and some of this is because I spend a lot of time on public transportation, but I think there’s also a more interesting thing going on at the interaction.
In some sense, civilisation works because we can participate in shared systems. The ability to get from point A to point B efficiently is one of the biggest changes of the last few hundred years of technological and civilisational development. The 90 minute commute I complain about that I take twice a day would have been several days of travel in 1700. This is an incredible achievement, and it’s one that we all depend on.
It also only works because we all behave in such a way that allows it to work, and I think this is at the root of a lot of my frustration.
I think the general guiding principle I am pointing at is something like this: If you rely on a system, you have an obligation to that system, and part of that obligation is to behave in such a way as to allow it to function well, so as to enable everyone else to be able to rely on it too.
Some of the consequences of this are like boarding, where I think there is an objectively correct answer, but I do think this is a case where it’s on us to go above and beyond that bare minimum, and put some thought and care into how we behave so as to make the world better for those who share systems with us.
In fairness, the vast majority of people I share trains with do in fact do this. I notice the outliers, because when you interact with hundreds of people every day, even if only 1% of people behave badly you’re going to run into several examples of bad behaviour per day, but most people on trains are good - or at least not bad - participants in the system.
But I think one way that is somewhat lacking that goes above and beyond just not behaving badly is to also correct other people’s bad behaviour. Ask people to use headphones, or to stand on the right, or to stop vaping on the platform. Become a participant in maintaining the system, not just an inhabitant of it, by teaching those around you how to do it better.
That number might be one. I’m writing this offline so I haven’t looked it up.
↩︎For example, it’s much easier to run with practice, which has a strong analogy to virtue ethics…
↩︎The one that actually annoys me the most is people watching videos on their phones without headphones. In contrast to the boarding principle, I don’t regard this one as an objective moral violation. I think it is incredibly rude, and I personally consider it immoral and judge people doing it to be assholes, but I think there’s a degree of genuine room for disagreement here, in which people are allowed to have worse opinions than me.
↩︎Actually I don’t have a good way to do that with the bottom of the stairs example. Another example where I do do that is to say loudly and crossly “Excuse me, could you please stand on the right?” when I am behind someone who is, like an absolute fucking monster, standing on the left of an escalator on the tube.
↩︎